Failure to Treat in Indiana

About Failure to Treat

Failure to treat occurs when a healthcare provider correctly diagnoses a condition but fails to provide appropriate treatment, refer the patient to a specialist, or follow established treatment protocols. This form of malpractice can be particularly frustrating for patients who sought care, received a correct diagnosis, and then experienced harm because the necessary next steps were never taken. These cases often involve systemic issues such as overloaded physicians, poor follow-up systems, or cost-driven treatment decisions.

Indiana Medical Malpractice Laws

Common Examples of Failure to Treat

• •Failing to prescribe appropriate medication after diagnosing a treatable condition
• •Not referring a patient to a specialist when the condition requires specialized care
• •Discharging a patient without an adequate treatment or follow-up plan
• •Ignoring or failing to act on abnormal test results that confirm a known diagnosis
• •Failure to provide appropriate post-surgical care or rehabilitation
• •Not ordering necessary follow-up imaging or biopsies after an initial diagnosis
• •Providing treatment that is outdated or inconsistent with current clinical guidelines

Key Facts

• ✓Failure to treat is legally distinct from misdiagnosis — the provider identified the condition correctly but did not act on it appropriately
• ✓Clinical practice guidelines from medical specialty organizations are often introduced as evidence to show what the standard treatment should have been
• ✓These cases frequently involve gaps in care coordination, particularly when multiple providers or healthcare systems are involved in a patient's treatment
• ✓Electronic health records that show a diagnosis was documented but no corresponding treatment plan was entered can be powerful evidence of failure to treat
• ✓Insurance-driven treatment denials may contribute to failure to treat, but the treating physician still has a legal duty to advocate for and pursue medically necessary care
• ✓Expert testimony in these cases typically focuses on what a competent physician in the same specialty would have done after reaching the same diagnosis
• ✓Indiana's Medical Malpractice Act requires claims against qualified providers to go through a medical review panel before filing in court.
• ✓The total damages cap of $1.8 million applies to qualified providers who participate in the Indiana Patient's Compensation Fund.
• ✓Individual provider liability is capped at $500,000 per occurrence, with the Patient's Compensation Fund covering the remainder up to $1.8 million.
• ✓Indiana follows a modified comparative fault system with a 51% bar.